Thursday, June 10th, 2004
10:32 am - I Wanna Be Sedated...  
I picked up two CDs at Newbury early in the week, Vs. by Mission of Burma, and Let's Knife by Shonen Knife. Both bands are highly regarded by folks in the music thread, and they were both on sale so what the heck.

Mission of Burma is a band that amassed huge critical acclaim in it's very short lifetime. They were also known for being very loud. Like, Hotblack Desiato loud. Apparently, one of the reasons they broke up is that the lead guitarist developed tinnitus. Vs. is their one and only studio album prior to their recent reunion record. I very much have a love-hate relationship with this album. I love their instrumental work. It's inventive, catchy, and just plain fun. I hate the vocals, which consist of the lead shouting as loud as he can, pretty much in monotone, pretty much the standard parody of every punk band ever shown on a sitcom. He's not singing. There is no melody line. I tuned out the vocals, and just listened to the music, which was great.

You run into that a lot in listening to punk, as if the shouting is one of the requirements to prove that you haven't sold out to the establishment. But then you have the Ramones, the ultimate punk band. There is melody, sometimes even harmony, in their songs. You can sing along to the Ramones. You can dance to the Ramones. The Ramones didn't have to shout to get attention. I just don't get the shouting.

Speaking of whom, the first thought that passes through one's mind when one first hears Shonen Knife is "Did I accidently stick a Ramones album into the player?" Instrumentally, they sound exactly like the Ramones. It's eerie. You keep expecting Joey to start in on "Rock N' Roll High School," but then this Japanese chick starts singing a pop song. It takes some getting used to. The band is a trio of Japanese women. The songs are these cheery little things about bicycling, or Barbie, or even two versions of the "Tortoise Brand Pot Scrubbing Cleaner's Theme." The lyrics are in English, but the singers' pronunciation and cadences are heavily Japanese, so most of the time you can't follow what they're singing unless you already know the lyrics. There's plenty of room for mishearing things, especially on songs like "Flying Jelly Attack." Still, it's all great fun, and nobody loses an eye.
 
 
Current Mood: musical
Current Music: "Flying Jelly Attack" -- Shonen Knife
 
 
( Post a new comment )
gchickgchick on June 10th, 2004 - 07:41 am
You've perfectly captured the joy that is Shonen Knife. Ramones + JPop + I Like Choco Bar.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
deborah gdebg on June 10th, 2004 - 08:27 am
You run into that a lot in listening to punk, as if the shouting is one of the requirements to prove that you haven't sold out to the establishment. But then you have the Ramones, the ultimate punk band. There is melody, sometimes even harmony, in their songs. You can sing along to the Ramones. You can dance to the Ramones. The Ramones didn't have to shout to get attention. I just don't get the shouting.

Tom Verlaine and Television. Patti Smith, with Ivan Kral and Lenny Kaye (the first man to ever pinch my ass). Talking Heads. Hell, the Clash. Richard Hell. Early Blondie (that first album). Elvis Costello.

There was really a lot of very musical punk, even if it was a direct backlash against the big squishy orchestral rock bands of the early to mid-seventies. Even the Sex Pistols were solidly musical. I love love love "Anarchy in the UK."
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
Hugh Likes Carrots: hughtheodosia on June 10th, 2004 - 10:13 am
The fun pop-rock side of punk is one of the great hidden secrets of Western Civ so far as I'm concerned.
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)